PepsiCo's voluntary pullback spans four 28-ounce flavors after regulators found tartrazine and Sunset Yellow FCF missing from ingredient labels.
More than 122,000 cases of Gatorade have been voluntarily recalled after PepsiCo discovered that certain 28-ounce bottles contained FD&C Yellow No. 5 and/or Yellow No. 6 without those dyes being declared on the labels, according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The recall, which covers Gatorade Lemon Lime, Lemon Lime Zero, Orange and Orange Zero, affected products distributed across 37 U.S. states, with lot dates stamped April, May or June 2027.
Costco Quietly Erases Pepsi's New Starry Soda as Coca-Cola Completes Its Food Court Comeback
How the Recall Unfolded From September to October
View this post on Instagram
PepsiCo initiated the voluntary recall on Sept. 25, 2026, according to FDA records cited across multiple reports. The FDA subsequently classified the action as a Class II recall on Oct. 2, and that classification became public on Oct. 5, when outlets including ABC News, CBS News and Health.com reported the enforcement details. The roughly 10-day gap between the company's internal action and the FDA's formal classification reflects the standard regulatory review process, in which the agency evaluates a manufacturer's self-reported recall before assigning it a risk category.
The FDA's enforcement database lists the precise figure as 122,021 cases, a number repeated consistently across ABC7, 6ABC, Medical Daily and other outlets reviewing the same federal notice. The consistency of that figure across independent reports underscores that it originates from a single authoritative source: the FDA's own enforcement report, rather than estimates generated by individual newsrooms.
FDA Finds Cyclospora in Mexican Farm Wastewater, but Source of Lettuce Contamination Remains Unclear
The Science Behind Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6
The two color additives at the center of the recall, Yellow No. 5 (tartrazine) and Yellow No. 6 (Sunset Yellow FCF), are both approved for use in U.S. food and beverage products. Yellow No. 5 carries a specific federal labeling mandate because a subset of consumers may experience sensitivity or allergic-type reactions to it, a requirement that does not apply uniformly to all color additives. Depending on the specific product and lot, one or both dyes may be present in the recalled Gatorade bottles without appearing anywhere in the ingredient statement.
This distinction matters because the recall is not rooted in a banned or unsafe substance. Both dyes remain legal additives in American food manufacturing. The issue instead centers on accurate disclosure: a product can be pulled from shelves even when every ingredient inside is permitted, if consumers are not being truthfully informed about what the bottle contains. That labeling failure, rather than any confirmed contamination or formulation defect, is what triggered PepsiCo's action.
What a Class II Designation Actually Means
The FDA classified this recall as Class II, the agency's middle tier of recall severity. By definition, that designation applies when exposure to or use of a product may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences, or when the probability of serious harm is considered remote. It is a narrower designation than Class I, which the FDA reserves for situations involving reasonable probability of serious injury or death.
Importantly, the Class II label does not mean the FDA has determined that every bottle poses a danger, nor does it confirm that any consumer has actually suffered an adverse reaction. The reports reviewed did not identify a confirmed outbreak of illness or cite a specific number of consumer complaints tied to the recall. The classification instead reflects a regulatory risk assessment based on the nature of the undeclared ingredient, not a finding of documented harm.
Where the Recalled Bottles Were Sold
The recalled Gatorade moved through a wide swath of the American retail market. Reports specifically name states including California, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Michigan, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, Utah and Washington, among the 37 states affected overall. Coverage from regional outlets such as the Fresno Bee and CBS Austin affiliate KATU confirms the recall's reach into both coastal and inland markets, spanning Idaho alongside the larger states listed above.
However, distribution at the state level does not mean every retail outlet in those states received the affected lots. Consumers are advised to check the specific flavor, the 28-ounce bottle size, and the printed lot date rather than assuming any Gatorade purchased within a recalled state is automatically affected. The available reporting does not include a complete, retailer-by-retailer breakdown of where the specific lots were sold, meaning shoppers should consult the FDA's enforcement record or PepsiCo's official recall notice for lot-level verification.
What Comes Next for Consumers and PepsiCo
Health.com reported that, while the FDA had not published detailed consumer instructions at the time of its article, the prudent response for anyone holding a matching product is to discard it or return it to the point of purchase. Consumers who suspect they experienced a reaction after drinking a recalled bottle are advised to seek medical attention, though no reports reviewed identify a specific clinical syndrome or treatment protocol tied to this incident.
Several questions remain unresolved in the public record. The reporting reviewed does not include a direct statement from a PepsiCo spokesperson explaining how the undeclared dyes entered the affected bottles, nor does it clarify whether the root cause involved formulation, ingredient substitution, packaging, or a quality-control lapse. No additional recall expansion, financial penalty, or court proceeding had been reported as of Oct. 5. The next developments to watch include a full lot-code list, a PepsiCo explanation of the root cause, and any FDA update on complaints or illnesses linked to the recalled Gatorade varieties.
