A real cop, a dead daughter, and a movie that critics say may be too kind to its hero.
Clean Hands, the 2026 crime drama starring Zach Braff, hits theaters October 16 after premiering at the Tribeca Festival on June 7 in New York. The film tells the true story of Hagerstown, Maryland narcotics officer Kevin Simmers, whose daughter Brooke died of a heroin overdose in 2015 at age 19.
Baththa Review: How a Locked Bathroom Turns a Feared Gangster Into a Softie
Clean Hands Review Zach Braff Faces Tough Questions From Critics
View this post on Instagram
Variety published its review of Clean Hands on October 13, and the verdict was not simple praise. The review calls the movie an 'uneasy' fact-based crime drama, arguing that its inspirational setup runs into trouble once you look at how Simmers actually behaved in real life. The critique does not deny the tragedy at the heart of the story. Instead, it questions whether writer-director Jake Allyn either bent the facts to make the drama hit harder, or simply skipped over parts of Simmers' real conduct that don't fit a heroic mold.
That tension matters because Clean Hands markets itself hard on its true story label. Tribeca's own program notes describe Simmers as a man balancing on 'the knife's edge of two disparate worlds,' a celebrated drug cop by day and a desperate father by night. Rotten Tomatoes frames Hagerstown itself as a major stop on the so-called Heroin Highway, tying one family's pain to a much bigger regional drug problem. Variety's review suggests viewers should watch that inspirational framing with a careful eye rather than take it at face value.
Tom Cruise's Digger Collapses at Box Office, Setting Up Warner Bros.' Costliest Flop in Years
Who Is Kevin Simmers and What Happened to Brooke
Kevin Simmers spent his career leading a narcotics task force in Hagerstown, enforcing a hard-line, arrest-first approach to drug crime. He believed criminal convictions mattered more than treatment, a mindset that gets challenged once his own daughter starts using drugs. Brooke Simmers' addiction reportedly began with prescription painkillers, identified in the film's marketing as Percocet, before progressing to heroin.
Brooke died from a heroin overdose on April 15, 2015. She was 19 years old. Her death pushed Kevin and his wife, Dana, to change direction completely. The couple founded Brooke's House, an all-women recovery residence meant to offer the kind of treatment and sober-living support they could not find in time for their own daughter. Production details note that one-third of the film's profits are pledged directly to Brooke's House, linking the movie's commercial success to ongoing recovery work.
Cast and Behind the Scenes Details of the Film
Zach Braff plays Kevin Simmers, while Esther McGregor, daughter of actor Ewan McGregor, plays Brooke. Abigail Spencer plays Dana, Brooke's mother, with Holt McCallany and Lucas Till rounding out the supporting cast. Festival materials single out McGregor's performance as especially intense, and a trailer released through People on September 15 leans heavily into the raw, difficult realism of addiction inside a police officer's own home.
Writer-director Jake Allyn, known for the film Ride, also produced Clean Hands. In a July interview with Georgia Entertainment, Allyn described the project as the true story of 'narcotics officer turned recovery advocate Kevin Simmers and his daughter Brooke,' calling their shared ordeal an 'unbelievable two-year journey with addiction.' Allyn said Simmers eventually gave up his badge to help build Brooke's House, turning personal loss into a new mission.
Why the True Story Label Deserves a Closer Look
Calling a movie based on a true story does not mean every scene, line of dialogue, or timeline detail is verified fact. Clean Hands compresses a two-year crisis into a feature film, and some choices made for pacing or emotional impact may not match court records or witness accounts exactly. Variety's review does not claim Brooke's addiction or death were invented. It raises a narrower but important point: dramatizing a cop's redemption arc can quietly smooth over uncomfortable details about how he acted while wearing the badge.
No public statement from Kevin Simmers, Dana Simmers, Brooke's House, or Hagerstown police officials has directly responded to Variety's criticism so far. Tribeca's own program description stuck to praising Braff's 'sobering portrayal' and McGregor's performance, without wading into questions of factual accuracy. That gap leaves room for more reporting once the film reaches wider audiences after its October 16 theatrical release.
What Comes Next for the Film and Brooke's House
With the theatrical release now set, public reaction is likely to grow well beyond festival circles and early trade reviews. Expect debate to center on three things: how accurately the film portrays the Simmers family, whether Kevin Simmers comes across as too heroic given Variety's concerns, and whether the film's partnership with Brooke's House turns into real support for women seeking recovery. No sequel, streaming date, or official rebuttal from the Simmers family has been confirmed yet, but the conversation around Clean Hands is clearly just getting started.
